If the max rainfall totals predicted by the Met Office come off, then the flooding this week will be every bit as bad (if not worse) than the Jan 2005 event. Max rainfall back then was at Shap (220mm) in 72 hrs. 250mm would be catastrophic if it occurred widely, and then on top of that there is the storm modelled for Saturday. I expect West Cumbria will be more badly affected this time, but maybe east Cumbria and Carlise (where main catchments are East of high ground) less badly. Keswick and Carlisle have enhanced their flood defences since 2005, but maybe not enough?