Indeed, an utterly pathetic and ridiculous forecast. It's worth commenting that the categories chosen - below average, close to average and above average are terciles, that is, the cut off temperature range defining each category has been selected so that each category has occured with equal frequency in the historical record. I seem to recall reading, that this year they were claiming that the winter season has a 41% chance of falling in the above average category, higher than the long term 33.3%. Even if these are true odds i.e. their forecasting theory is sound, it still implies a 59% chance that the winter season will be either close to average or below average. It would have been far better and less irritating had they simply said that no strong signal has been detected this year.