The warming (to the mid 90s, now ended) was at the same pace since the end of the Little Ice Age, there is no evidence that CO2 sped up this escape from the LIA. Only the fraudulent hockey stick which tried and failed to rewrite climatic history present a different view. We now know that statistically it was flawed thanks to StMac, and we also know the reasons why it was flawed. Mann used proxies upside down, used proxies that weren't proxies, spliced temperature data onto these nonproxies (a "foolish and incorrect thing to do" in his own words), cherry-picked individual trees that he liked the tree-ring shape of, and then convinced his friends to back him up by intimidating previously respected climatic journals. Mann, Jones, and Briffa, the holy trinity who ruined climate science and set it back 20 years. Hopefully they won' set our economies back by an even longer period. The emails back up that Mann, Jones and Briffa knew that the hockey stick was flawed and carried on regardless because they knew better. Unfortunately there were people around who caught them on their lying and outed them. The emails are just the final pieces of the jigsaw and realists can now see the whole thing was an egotistical fraud all along. This is good news. We can now direct the funds that would otherwise be wasted towards improving the environment and aiding human advancement in the developing world, rather than throwing them down a drain of trashed science.