No, whether GP is right, nearly right or completely wrong with his summer forecast is irrelevant in my opinion, science and forecasting methods are only going to get better with time IMO, i know there are people that think that LRFs are not accurate enough to be published at the moment and they may have a valid argument, although i would rather have them there to be able to evaluate to be honest but the point is they are far more likely to be a thing of the future than a thing of the past as technology improves.