I dont wish to bash the met office too much because i still belive generally they do great job, however it was not just the BBQ summer failure, there was in my opinion a more schoolboy error in their final seasonal forecast before they ditched it (i dont know whether this was the final straw and they ditched it as a result), but the winter forecast 2009-2010 was done on a % basis, i cant remeber what exactly they said at the start but it was odds on a milder than average winter but in their monthly appraisal of the initail forecast they didnt change it that much, and baring in mind this was at the end of december 2009 when we had already had a cold start and all the model output, other outlets and even their own monthly forecast was hinting at severe cold for at the very least the first 2 weeks of January, it would have taken a monumental spell of double figures max temps in feb if it was going to end up a milder than average winter, and as we all know it didnt and was pretty cold right the way through though the snow was less frequent and heavy and more localised than in Jan.