Jump to content
Snow?
Local
Radar
Cold?

jonboy

Members
  • Posts

    1,824
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by jonboy

  1.  WYorksWeather There are 2 factors at play. Firstly the 2 forcings are totally different  The SO2 impact which has a cooling effect dissipated below background levels within 12/18 months and the amount injected into the atmosphere was nothing exceptional. Whereas the water vapor was exceptional and is expected to last between 5 and 10 years. It is also clear that the water vapor took some 18 months to impact southern and northern hemispheres and given the lessening impact of the SO2 during that period that is likely to explain the lag.

    The cooling effect of SO2 has gone we are left with the warming effect of the excess water vapor which gives the net radiative forcing of +0.15Wm-2 this cannot be ignored when discussing the present warming.

    On a side note I see that that volcanic activity around Hunga Tonga is on the increase again perhaps we have not seen the last of this volcano!!  

  2.  Derecho I assume from your comments that you are in the camp of that suggests water vapor has no role whatsoever in warming. In my view such a position is foolhardy. The quoted +0.15Wm-2 is radiative forcing. If you accept that CO2 has a radiative forcing effect then you should accept that water vapor also has a contribution. 

    In regard to your last statement I would counter why doesn't CO2 increase have an immediate effect? Its called lag.

  3. I am going to be controversial. Research shows that the likely impact of hunga tonga due to the stratospheric increase in H2O to be about +0.15Wm-2 radiative forcing this is compared to a forcing of +0.25Wm-2 for the increase in CO2 between the period of 1995 to 2006. Given that the initial plume was located more across the equatorial belt it is no surprise to me that we have seen the oceans warm. we will not see a decline in temperatures until we see this additional water vapor return to earth. Estimates put this at anything from 5 to 10 years. The world is in for a soggy warm few years yet.

    The Hunga Tonga‐Hunga Ha'apai Hydration of the Stratosphere - Millán - 2022 - Geophysical Research Letters - Wiley Online Library

     

  4.  WYorksWeather wow why am I not surprised by your statement. 

    So it appears that changing attitudes to climate change means a hardening of attitudes that holds no truck with anyone who may disagree in the slightest with your definition. 

    Perhaps this thread should close because no matter what your opinion might be if it differs your a denier.

    To be clear therefore I'm a denier. Unbelievable 

    • Like 1
  5. One issue I have in regard to the whole climate change discussions is that each element of emission is taken in isolation without a fully rounded discussion on consequence.

    An example is electric cars. As a singular subject electric cars are less polluting in carbon terms that petrol or diesel in regard to emissions. However this carbon cycle needs to factor in also the degradation to our roads due to increased weight hence the need for greater/more often renewal. The additional pollution of greater tire degradation and thus greater tire wear. The need to change battery assemblies at least once in the life time of the vehicle. If you added the whole carbon cycle I am certain electric vehicles wouldn't look so attractive.   

    • Like 3
    • Thanks 1
  6.  Midlands Ice Age

    17 minutes ago, Midlands Ice Age said:

    So why are we seeing increased and earlier ice formation particularly for this winter?

    for what its worth we know that snow fall can help in the formation of sea ice. We have seen this winter an increase in the intensity of both rainfall and snowfall which I would suggest is a result of the extra water vapour in the stratosphere, as a result of Hunga Tonga, making its way back to earth. This increase in intensity of any early snowfall would in my opinion have helped in the early ice formation this year. We may well see this next year also but thereafter unlikely.

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...