A bit early yet to pass judgement on GP's winter forecast in my view, as Winter hasn't finished.
Seems to be pretty accurate so far - December and January pretty much spot on - February good start, but looking shaky for remainder.
I think, generally, even though i believe it wasn't 'officially' published, the MetO has been pretty good as well.
Winter '11/'12 hasn't delivered in terms of 'wants' in these parts though - in fact poor from a snow perspective - come to think of it v poor!
Question for the more knowledgeable on NW - whatever has happened to those Channel Low events the South West used to see in many a winter? - sometimes only 1 or 2 each winter (and not every winter i know) but they weren't uncommon 25+ years ago. I've seen archive news stuff that documents these events as quite common from the 19th century and up to the 1980s.